Who knows how Canada's constitution works? It's not always me, but I can assure you that it is definitely not 95% of the pissy 18-year-olds who've chosen to share their indignance with the world via the message board of "I'm against the Liberal coup d'état".
Firstly...ok. I know that anyone who's reading my blog already gets this, but OH GOD STOP CALLING IT A "COUP". This is a coup. This is a coup. This is a coup, too. What is happening in Canada is a peaceful, legal, perfectly constitutional response to a Cabinet that has lost the confidence of the House. Furthermore, it's already happened in Canada, both officially and unofficially. Everybody take a breath.
While you're breathing, try to think for a moment about your response to the term "coalition government". I saw an awful lot of "look at Italy and Israel!!!! Coalitions are doomed to failure!!!!!1!!" And I suppose you have a point, Mr. "Jack Layton is a Communist" of St. Albert Catholic High School, especially when you consider how much more Canada has in common with Israel than with Sweden, Ireland, Germany, or any other of the numerous stable, peaceful democracies listed here. I hear Switzerland is a real hell-hole these days - good thing those train tickets to Zurich are refundable.
I'm going to talk about Austria for a minute, since its the only country that I've had the good fortune to live in under a coalition government, not to mention during an election of same. I'll be the first to admit that Austrian politics fall on the "kind of messed" side of the (democratic) political spectrum. Full disclosure: in the past two months, the following things have happened.
- An election occurred, after the previous coalition government split following disagreement over Austria's level of involvement in and committment to the EU
- 16-to-18-year-olds, voting in their first election in Austrian history, overwhelmingly tilted to the far-right, leading to a minority parliament with representation from the center-left (29%), center-right (26%), far right (18%), batshit-crazy right (11%), and green (10%) parties
- Immediately following the elections, two of the major parties (center-right and green) changed leaders, seemingly overnight
- The overly-tanned and immensely-popular-in-certain-circles leader of the batshit-crazies died in a car accident, leaving his 28-year-old protegé/best friend/rumoured lover to take the helm
- After considerable soul-searching, the leader of the center-right party rejects appeals from the far right to form government, and instead reaches out to the leader of the center-left
- They take their sweet-ass time coming to a consensus on policy and cabinet positions, leaving plenty of time for the newly-minted Saviour of the Batshit-Crazies to resign his party's house leadership, take a week to think about it, and then quit politics altogether to make a movie about his deceased mentor/maybe-boyfriend and weep publicly
- The leader of the center-right gets cold feet, and publicly submits "10 Important Questions" to his would-be coalition partner. He NEEDS ANSWERS! One of the questions may have been, "do you like me or like like me?"
- The center-left guy answers the questions the next day in a national newspaper, and the government is formed in the next week. The leader of the center-left (Werner Faymann) is the new Chancellor, Joseph Proll (center-right kingmaker) is Vice-Chancellor, and Cabinet positions were split evenly between the parties.
I don't mean to paint Austria as an idyllic, post-partisan dreamworld - it's not, and there are issues. The point is that there has come to Europe a sense that government consists of everyone who has been elected to it. That perhaps MPs should think of governing before they think of securing their legacies. That perhaps agendas should be discussed and revised, rather than imposed. That perhaps everyone in Canada should relax and think about things before screaming about socialists, separatists, and not-a-leaders (oh my!).
And while I'm thinking about it, someone should tell Stephen Harper that, while I'm holding in my Nelson laugh in the spirit of cooperation, a bully is not the same thing as a leader. Leaders talk to people, leaders inspire, leaders take counsel, and above all, leaders get shit done. Something about living in glass PM residences and not throwing parliamentary maces...? Man, I can't wait to see what happens.
Oh yeah, and Austria also has proportional representation. Just in case you were wondering.
10 comments:
Good post. After the last Canadian election sneaked up on me unawares and startled me into facing the decision of either voting on something I knew nothing about or not voting (both bad choices), I have made an effort to follow Canadian politics. And I would like to say now that my former suspicions that I didn't like Harper have been dramatically confirmed. I don't like Harper. Since I have long viewed the NDP as the conscience that the Liberal party needs to effectively function without getting drunk on power and growing corrupt, I think a coalition government between the two makes an awful lot of sense. Also, despite my strong dislike of the Bloc, I do feel kind of bad for them in their pariah-like status as each party fights over who was willing to get in bed with them and "deal with the devil" so to speak. Who knew Canadian politics were actually interesting?
Note: this comment is identical to my deleted one, just with an embarrassing typo fixed. I hope it was the only one.
I read your post about not voting just after the Canadian election, and I meant to chide you thoroughly about it (especially considering the hoops I jumped through in an ultimately failed attempt to cast an absentee ballot, but that's another story). I'm glad you care now!
Certainly I have concerns about the BQ being allowed anywhere near Cabinet (yes, I know they wouldn't actually be allocated any posts), and I'll hopefully have time to address this in a couple of days. In the meantime, I'll be sitting here and waiting patiently for the internet to tell me what Michelle Jean does. I really, really wish I was at home right now.
Speaking of home, are you going back to Victoria for Christmas, and/or stopping in Toronto for any period of time?
I complained about the bully/leader confusion during our last election. The "strong leader" myth being distressingly prevalent is the only way I can explain the hate-on so many otherwise reasonable people have for Stéphane Dion.
Anyway, via Facebook, if you hadn't noticed:
"Michael is sickened by the power-hungry, unprincipled Liberal caucus trying to steal power through the backdoor."
"Kelvin is disappointed that any political party will sell it's soul to a separatist party for a shot to power."
The latter is a past exec of EWB UofT. I'm sure the cognitive dissonance is deafening.
PR can't come soon enough.
Also, I weep to see I am no longer on your blogroll. I shall try and shape up so I can be readmitted :P
Never trust anyone who abuses apostrophes. I mean, it might (I stress "might") be ok in a text message to OMIT the apostrophe because it's hard to find where it is on the keypad, but to add an EXTRA apostrophe is just moronic. It's confirmation that you actually believe it's right. Paul - add http://www.apostropheabuse.com/
as a comment to Mr. Kelvin's comment.
Also, if anyone comes across an equally thoughtful blog post or article that represents the other side, I would love to see it. Perhaps you all know by now that my lifelong dream is to meet a rational conservative that can present "the other side" without resorting to name calling or seeking to tip the terms of debate in his favour. I always seek to be impartial, but perhaps "rational" and "impartial" are the precise qualities that are the antithesis of being conservative, and thus my request is by definition impossible. If that is not so, prove me wrong!
Calden: Sadly, I'm going to be in Austria for Christmas (plane tickets expensive, being paid less than the custodial staff, saving vacation time for parents' visit and trip to Turkey). Are you going back to BC?
Paul: Eeep. Your site was not removed so much as never added (I think you were in the middle of a posting drought when I made the list). Since remedied! I'd seen Mike's status but not Kelvin's. Ugh.
Bob: Totally with you on the apostrophe abuse. Boils my blood.
No, I'm going to be in Peru for Christmas. My brother-in-law has trouble getting a visa to come to Canada, so we decided to go south for Christmas... it's going to be weird, not having any snow.
Post a Comment